So Many Videos, So Little Faith. The World Looks Sad.

An eight-year-old book, focused on Japan’s economy and not published in an English translation, has posed timely questions about a deficit we see growing everywhere—a spiritual deficit, that is.

Kenichi Ohmae’s How to Ignite the Low Desire Society, widely discussed online, is a good start for monitoring Japan and other nations as they strive to maximize their financial and cultural wellness.

But, as the videos popping up on YouTube seem to testify, the dialogue is largely silent about one important force: personal faith. Economics and politics show only part of the picture.

Missing in Japan’s Macroeconomy

Ohmae, trained as an engineer, focuses on systems: Young adults—call them Japan’s “Gen Z”—lack ambition. They have detached from older expectations and don’t even save for the future. The country is losing its collective ability to dream big.

To some, countercultural detachment might sound downright Franciscan. Saint Francis of Assisi is beloved as a role model who embraced simple living and shed his prideful materialism for immersion in divine love and shared joy. He would remind us today that he didn’t dream small. Moderating earthly desires meant something different to him than to secular modernity.

Instead of reining in its ambitions, Japan, a former powerhouse of economic growth in Asia, should consider re-directing them, Francis might say. Jesus taught that the “poor in spirit” will find happiness, but that phrase referred to humility—not to spiritual apathy, which is called acedia.

This negative diagnosis could be applied not only to Japan, but to China and South Korea, and indeed to Western civilization. We should ponder the prospect that any nations striving to revive and sustain their fiscal strength, but not prioritizing faith for humanity’s fulfillment, will face outbreaks of acedia. Those reliant on a secular vocabulary will translate the problem as “low desire.”

One senses the sadness on YouTube, expressed in the voices of people with first-hand knowledge. The algorithms in my app introduced me first to videos by Louis Zhao, a twenty-something of Chinese parentage.

He says years of working for an international tech-consulting firm have allowed him to encounter a spectrum of individuals, countries, and social systems.

Zhao’s channel, at least the content without a paywall, is vague about whether he lives in Japan or China or elsewhere. But much of his commentary looks at Japan through a philosophical lens. This global citizen admits that his career, requiring remote work at the computer day and night, has left him anxious and frustrated as he faces business slowdowns and layoffs.

“Something peculiar is happening in Japan,” according to an episode he posted last year about his “low desire” insights. “People there, especially young people, don’t seem to want things anymore….

“They’ve stopped going for promotions at their jobs, preferring simply to go through the motions in the office. They’ve stopped pursuing hobbies, preferring simple routines or passive entertainment.”

Zhao continues: “They prefer renting over buying homes, taking public transport over owning cars, and they prefer to keep the money they’ve saved as cash over investing into assets. Half of all marriages are sexless or nearly sexless.”

And the nation’s fertility rate is “at an all-time low,” far under population-replacement levels. “In fact, many young adults have stopped looking for love altogether.”

Other videos discuss the emergence in Japan of “herbivore men” whose gentleness downplays past paradigms like the hyper-diligent “salaryman” with a warrior’s heart.

These days, “the absence of progress is the norm” in many people’s lives, Zhao says. As they play it safe amid financial insecurity, a Buddhist teaching comes to his mind: “The end of desire is the end of suffering.”

Zhao concludes that the Japanese “have become afraid to hope.” He quotes the author Ohmae, calling this cultural shift an “abnormality” unique to Japan.

However, the tendency has many faces.

China and South Korea: Different Orientations

Four months ago, a 33-year-old woman named Chunchun, living in Shanghai, posted a video titled “Why Chinese Daily Life Vloggers are Exploding on YouTube.” She explains that her country has banned the platform for more than a decade, but virtual private network (VPN) technology provides many people the access they crave.

My own fact-check with my browser’s AI (which itself needs fact-checking) affirmed: “There appears to have been an increase in the number and visibility of Chinese citizens and China-based organizations posting on YouTube,” although there are no official statistics.

Chunchun reports, “For many ordinary young people in China, life no longer feels like a straight road. Some people are struggling to find jobs. Some people still have jobs, but their salaries are shrinking and their workload is increasing” while layoffs still loom.

She and others have established YouTube channels as “a back-up plan” to bring in modest revenues. But she says the outreach by young adults primarily reflects their search for identity and meaning—sharing details of their lives, including their “anxieties” about stability, and wondering how life is different elsewhere.

The desire to be understood as individuals is not peculiar to the young-ish Chinese adults. A video posted two weeks ago by Yanning describes her life as a 46-year-old divorcee and mother in Shanghai. She says Chinese people of her age quip to each other that they are “too young to live and too young to die.”

At her age, “it feels like every door has been closed on you.” Every person seems “to be born with a program already installed”—a rush to get a good education, get a job, buy a car, buy a home, get married, and have children. Women are called “leftovers” if they are not married by age 30, and finding a job after 35 is getting harder, Yanning says.

On the “Dr. Jonathan Tam” channel from South Korea, YouTube received this commentary five months ago: “Korea’s ‘gender war’ is out of control.”

Each sex has claimed underdog status, he says, and both are active in a political environment where protest is welcome. Governmental, economic, and cultural conditions have prompted major affordability debates related to marriage, housing, and child-raising expenses.

Tam offers a summary analysis: “Every major economy in East Asia is running the same experiment.” Very low fertility rates help to make the future look fragile.

In Japan, people are responding with little public polarization but quiet resignation, according to Tam. In China, some conflict and rogue behavior occurs among individuals, but the Communist Party and old traditions make people reticent. In South Korea, affordability and individuality are being tackled as part of politicized gender battles.

This assessment—similar situations with each population forging different, uneasy reactions—should prompt curiosity about acedia creeping into Western societies.

Where’s the Belief?

Sadly, the factor of personal faith, which could generate a fuller, broader understanding of low desire, is seldom mentioned by the content creators.

If truth-seeking discussion and reflection about basic morality and human dignity could instead be highlighted for worldwide media attention, nations might find more space for pinpointing problems, maybe addressing them.

Ironically, in other channel categories on YouTube, the platform hosts an abundance of religious content, such as commentary based on Judeo-Christian values. But preachers seem to address mostly the people and issues in their countries of origin. That’s odd because religion is one of the few sources of guidance which inherently crosses borders; many viewers must be hungry to receive transcendent lessons that offer peace through empathy.

Faith leaders should consider expanding the scope of their messages to build global awareness. It’s an online growth opportunity. Catholics have a pope who speaks and acts globally, and YouTube is just one of the tools amplifying reports from vaticannews.va.

Meanwhile, plenty of secular pundits with big audiences in mass media and social platforms tend to posit their policy solutions on a nation-by-nation or ideology-by-ideology basis. Americans tend to focus on their own problems, sidelining other countries which we label and judge without enough reflection about their profound cultures and concerns.

Video aficionados should help to lead the way in recognizing all people as children of God. We need a more panoramic spirit of inquiry to motivate our individual educational browsing. We can take arm-chair “world tours” and customize them using the best of YouTube content. That implies favoring long-form, substantive presentations, not “shorts” or “reels” or “slop” which destroy our attention spans.

If we commit to use media purposefully and conscientiously, we can fulfill promises long implicit in the Internet—encountering global similarities and differences among the elites and the marginalized alike, and finding solidarity in the essential human traits of mind, heart, and soul, alongside the bonus of personal uniqueness. The world’s perplexity cries out for greater “web”-wide community.

The digital media must continue evolving into a place where we “invite each other in” for authentic acquaintance, freed from the business model of trauma that enrages. If we promote tools like YouTube as meaningful places of storytelling and connection, we will assemble instead for drama that engages.

The platform has become the most popular app for the smart TVs in our living rooms. With the exception of books, it beats other media for access to history, context, critical thinking, and higher perspectives.

St. Francis and Channels of Peace

A modern-day St. Francis would gravitate toward YouTube immediately. During his life, he marveled at God’s profound imprint on all of creation, writ large and in tiny detail.

Francis would appreciate content creators reaching out to each other, envisioning a human ecology where no one’s talent should go to waste (whether or not it is monetized).

The saint would worry about any spiritual deficits blocking the conversion of hearts toward the true, the good, and the beautiful. He would be glad that folks were talking with each other, not with soulless chatbots.

He would watch and listen, eager to hear people mention families and communities, those whom they love, what they’re thankful for, and the peace of mind they’re finding with God.

If video presenters spoke instead of isolation and low desire, Francis’s instinct for gentle evangelization would kick in.

The holy “influencer” from the 13th century might probe these cases (using the “comments” section!), hoping people were in transition, seeking better balance in life. He would believe their souls are still ready to share knowledge and passions for the common good.

He would be distressed if oversimplified ideas and stagnant self-preservation had become ends in themselves. He would prayerfully point the anxious and isolated toward a hope that transcends earthly preoccupations and energizes human worldviews with redemptive love.

This would be a “high desire” that can heal low desire. Note that it does not require, or encourage, big desires. Recent obsessions with “supersizing” our accomplishments have misdirected world leaders and business elites, opening the door to Tower of Babel crises. Now, everyone has a stake in diagnosing and treating this virus of “affluenza,” which helped to plant the seeds of acedia.

MagisAI, the research tool developed by the Jesuit-run Magis Center for catechetics, says acedia has multiple causes. Perhaps the biggest blame goes to “emotional desolation, such as feelings of emptiness or lack of efficacy” when living for oneself alone. This erodes the body politic.

Magis goes on, “People who prioritize ego-satisfaction” or adopt models of prideful detachment often experience jealousy, fear of failure, blame, and resentment.” One wonders if Western civilization might also see it expressed as narcissism, nihilism, victim-thinking, hatred, and violence.

Judging with Open Minds and Open Apps

Of course, we should avoid negative stereotypes or accusations, especially if they’re based on videos or social media posts of uncertain origin. But, amid the current chaos of generational and technological change, lots of content can foster a sense of connection, even as AI tools point us toward competition and fear.

Can human beings around the world keep the creative spirit alive? They reportedly upload five hundred hours of video to the platform every minute. The stories show no sign of ending, and they suggest that change is possible.

We benefit from remembering the presenters in videos mentioned above. We see the nations of East Asia going through their own turmoil, and we can understand each other better.

If those young people are choosing to want less, maybe it’s because the world has been wanting some things too much, or wanting the wrong things. If they’re craving to tell their stories, perhaps time-honored messages haven’t been carried forward well, or the value of new stories is not yet clear.

Their evolving pathways, though filled with tension, might lead to lessons for us all—the development of new friends and relationships, groups forming to build fresh expertise and ideas for serving society. Perhaps they’ll discuss philosophy or theology, rediscovering the deep roots in both East and West.

We can hope that humanity’s growing awareness of moral issues will set the stage for progress among our leaders. A surge of generous cooperation would be a great gift at this week’s meeting of Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, and Xi Jinping.

The pressure is on to translate economic and political stances into a comfortable, candid language of faces and voices.

Nations struggling to balance humanity’s needs should budget more time and talent to grapple with spiritual deficits, lest they hit the tipping point of fiscal and moral bankruptcy.

At our laptops and phones, our role is to stay tuned. We have awe-inspiring resources—and we are awe-inspiring  resources—ready for further viewing, reading, collaboration, and reasoning in a global gallery where images and imaginations get renewed.

As we keep searching, St. Francis might suggest two algorithms to guide us: re-attaching to the ultimate content creator and elevating our worldviews with high desire.

Image from Microsoft Bing’s Co-Pilot AI designer.

Unknown's avatar

About Bill Schmitt

Bill Schmitt is a Catholic journalist, author, educator, and marketing-communications specialist whose recent work can be seen on the Magis Center blog, in the diocesan newspaper of the Diocese of Albany, and in commentaries at “Phronesis in Pieces” on the Substack platform and at “OnWord.net”. As a secular reporter/editor, he worked at Gannett Westchester Newspapers, McGraw-Hill, Cahners Business Information, Kiplinger Washington Letter, and Chemical Week magazine. Bill has been an adjunct professor of English and media at several schools, including Fordham University and the U of Notre Dame. Full bio: Click "About" at billschmitt.substack.com
This entry was posted in Education, Prayer, Spirit of communication. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply